Man

 

 

The traducian theory

 

 

The traducian theory holds that ‘the immaterial part of man is imparted through procreation so that the individual receives his whole person from his parents.’ In other words, this theory holds that when God created Adam and Eve, He endowed them with the power to reproduce after their own image, and this power includes both the material and immaterial parts of man, that is, both the body and the soul. This theory was accepted by Tertullian (2nd and 3rd centuries AD), by Augustine (354 - 430 AD), by Lutherans, and by most modern theologians (Chafer, Bancroft, Delitzsch).

 

Confutation

 

The Scripture teaches that the soul is created by God, as it is written: “For I will not contend for ever, neither will I be always wroth: for the spirit should fail before me, and the souls which I have made.” (Isaiah 57:16).

Those who hold the traducian theory affirm that the creation theory (the one I accept and teach) can’t be accepted because Genesis 2:1-2 tells us that God ceased creating after the sixth day, while this theory says that God creates the soul of every child who is to be born. Well, then, how is it that Elihu, one of the descendants of Adam, said: “The Spirit of God has made me ….” (Job 33:4 – NKJV)? Is it not because he believed that God had created both his body and his soul? Therefore, it is true that God gave man and woman the power to reproduce after their own image, but this reproduction always involves the work of God. In other words, it is God who makes our body and soul. However, while the body is from the earth (for it is the product of the union of man and woman), the soul is from God (for it is not material), thus the soul can’t come from the parents. The soul is not material, that’s why physical parents can’t produce it.

The argument according to which God ceased creating after the sixth day, and consequently He can’t create the soul of every child who is to be born, is nullified by what the prophet Amos says: “For behold, He who forms mountains, and creates the wind ….” (Amos 4:13 – NKJV), for the wind was created by God in the beginning, yet the Word of God says that God creates it.

 

 

 

Back