Eschatology
|
Reincarnation |
![]()
|
Reincarnation
is the belief that the soul (one’s incorporeal true self) passes from one
body to another in a series of incarnated existences. |
|
The
classic form of the reincarnation doctrine was formulated in |
|
Today
reincarnation is accepted also by millions of people in the West. It began to
be spread in the Western World around the end of the nineteenth century by
the Theosophical Society, and later by Anthroposophy. After the second World War,
their intense ministry, combined with that of many Eastern gurus (a guru is a
teacher, in the sense of being a manifestation of Brahman, which is the
ultimate reality), and especially the efforts of the New Age Movement,
determined a wide acceptance of reincarnation in our society today.
Testimonies from prominent people such as Shirley MacLaine and actor Glenn
Ford, who tell of their ‘former lives’, have helped spread the belief in
reincarnation. |
|
Let
us look now closely at what the reincarnation doctrine says. I will expound
reincarnation according to the Hindu point of view. |
|
First
of all, this doctrine affirms that the human soul (atman) is eternal and
divine, that is, a part of Brahman (like a limb in a body or a branch of a
tree), which is another name for God. According to Hinduism, Brahman is the
ultimate reality: formless, inexpressible, unknowable, and unknowing; neither
personal nor impersonal; both Creator and all that is created. |
|
Secondly,
it affirms that we have lived other lives before, therefore this is not the
first life we are living on the earth, because when the soul leaves a body it
goes into another body. This concept is expressed in the Bhagavad-Gita (the
most popular of the Hindu scriptures) in this way: ‘Just as the self advances
through childhood, youth and old age in its physical body, so it advances to
another body after death. The wise person is not confused by this change
called death (2,13). Just as the body casts off worn
out clothes and puts on new ones, so the infinite, immortal self casts off
worn out bodies and enters into new ones (2,22).’ |
|
Thirdly,
the doctrine of reincarnation holds that we who are on the earth are or
experience what we deserve to be or to experience according to our behaviour
in the previous lives. In other words, the good we receive on the earth is
the reward for the former good deeds, while the harm we receive is the
punishment for the evil deeds committed in the previous lives. Therefore, if
one is born in a rich family or is healthy, that means that he has a good
karma, while if one is born in a poor family or sick and during his life
experiences all kinds of misfortunes, that means
that he has a bad karma. ‘It’s his karma!’, that’s what reincarnationists
affirm in order to explain why men are rich or poor, learned or unlearned,
healthy or sick, or why certain incidents happen in their lives. Karma
literally means ‘action’ and is the law of cause and effect which determines
destiny or fate, that is to say, the law which says that we will reap (in the
next earthly life) what we sow (in this life). This ‘law’ is expressed in the
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (4,4,5): ‘According as one acts, according as one behaves,
so does he become. The doer of good becomes good. The doer of evil becomes
evil. One becomes virtuous by virtuous action, bad by bad action.’ Therefore
reincarnation (samsara) is the practical way in which one reaps the fruits of
his deeds. Therefore, the soul is forced to enter a new material existence
until all karmic debt is paid: "By means of thought, touch, sight and
passions and by the abundance of food and drink there are birth and
development of the (embodied) self. According to his deeds, the embodied self
assumes successively various forms in various conditions" (Shvetashvatara Upanishad 5,11). In the Puranas specific destinies are figured for
each kind of ‘sin’ one performs: ‘The murderer of a Brahmin becomes
consumptive, the killer of a cow becomes hump-backed and imbecile, the murderer
of a virgin becomes leprous - all three born as outcastes. The slayer of a
woman and the destroyer of embryos becomes a savage full of diseases; who
commits illicit intercourse, a eunuch; who goes with his teacher’s wife,
disease-skinned. The eater of flesh becomes very red; the drinker of
intoxicants, one with discolored teeth.... Who steals food becomes a rat; who
steals grain becomes a locust... perfumes, a muskrat; honey, a gadfly; flesh,
a vulture; and salt, an ant.... Who commits unnatural vice becomes a village
pig; who consorts with a Sudra woman becomes a bull; who is passionate
becomes a lustful horse.... These and other signs and births are seen to be
the karma of the embodied, made by themselves in
this world. Thus the makers of bad karma, having experienced the tortures of
hell, are reborn with the residues of their sins, in these stated forms
(Garuda Purana 5). It must be said, however, that in the West, animals have
been excluded from the cycle of reincarnation. |
|
Those
who accept reincarnation assert that the law of karma is taught also by the
Bible, for it is written in the epistle to the Galatians: “Whatever a man
sows, that he will also reap” (Galatians 6:7 – NKJV). According to the law of
cause and effect, one cannot experience the consequences of all his deeds in
one life, because while on the one hand he reaps in this life the fruits of
his previous deeds, on the other hand he does some other deeds which need to
be rewarded or punished in the next life. In other words, a man cannot pay
off his karmic debt through one life, that is, he cannot purify himself (or
expiate his karma) in one life; so he needs to be reincarnated again and
again. That’s why Hinduism speaks of a cycle of reincarnation called samsara. However, it is possible for a
man to be delivered from this cycle of reincarnation. This deliverance is
called moksha, and it can be
achieved through yoga (literally
‘yoking’), which is an Eastern practice – consisting of peculiar bodily
postures and breath control - designed to induce a state of trance which
supposedly allows the mind to be drawn upward into a yoking with Brahman. It
is a means of withdrawal from the world of illusion (maya) to seek the only true Reality, that is, Brahman. Let me
tell you something more about this so called liberation or salvation. It is
achieved by man when the individual soul (atman)
returns to union with the universal soul (Brahman)
again, that is to say, when man ‘realizes’ that he himself is Brahman, that
he and all the universe are one and the same being. In other words, this
liberation is achieved when man is delivered from the ‘illusion’ (maya) that the individual soul is
different from the universal soul (Brahman).
Then pain and suffering end. Here is what the Bhagavad-Gita says about this liberation:
‘The great souls having achieved ultimate perfection take refute of Me, never
again assume this transitory birth full of misery’ (8,15).
However, according to orthodox Hinduism, there is no ultimate escape from maya, and one must eventually return
to the cycle of deaths and rebirths again. Moksha is merely a temporary rest, another stage on the wheel of
existence that goes round and round endlessly, repeating itself every 4.32
billion years. |
|
To
sum up, the doctrine of reincarnation is based on the following principles: |
|
the
soul is eternal and divine, that is, a part of God (that is called Brahman),
which is impersonal (a sort of cosmic energy); |
|
the
human soul has been born into the human body after it has lived in another living
being or in other living beings; |
|
the
circumstances of man’s life, that is, both the good and the bad events, both
the pleasant and the unpleasant ones, which take place in man’s life, are
nothing but the result of his deeds done in his previous lives; |
|
after
death man’s soul will continue to be incarnated on the earth into another
human being (or even into some animals) to be rewarded for the good things he
is doing and to be punished for the evil deeds he has done (that is, to
expiate his karma); |
|
there
is hope of putting an end to the cycle of reincarnation (according to some,
however, there is no hope of escaping from this cycle of deaths and
rebirths); |
|
in
order to be delivered from this cycle of reincarnation, a man must practice yoga; |
|
when
man becomes Brahman or rather when he returns to union with Brahman again
(through yoga) he will realize his divine nature for he will be delivered
from the illusion that he is not God, then the cycle of reincarnation will
end for he will be perfect; |
|
evil
deeds cannot be forgiven for a man must expiate all of them in the following
lives; |
|
man must not give account of
his deeds to God but to himself. |
|
|
|
Confutation |
|
|
|
Now
I am going to refute reincarnation through the Holy Scripture |
|
|
|
1)
The Holy Scripture teaches that God is not a cosmic energy, that is, an
impersonal God, but a living being who speaks, as it is written: “God said
unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish [fill] the earth, and subdue
it: and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air,
and over every living thing that moveth upon the earth.” (Genesis |
|
|
|
2)
The Holy Scripture teaches that man is not part of God, that is to say, he is
not an emanation of God (therefore man is not a divine being), but he is a
creature of God (cf. Genesis 2:7 and Psalm 139:13-15) who needs to be
reconciled to His Creator for he is an enemy of God in his mind and deeds,
and this he can do only in this life, for it is written: “Be reconciled to
God ….. Behold, now is the accepted time; behold, now is the day of
salvation” (2 Corinthians |
|
|
|
3)
The Holy Scripture teaches that our soul did not exist before our birth, for
it was created together with our body by God (we can’t say, however, exactly
when our soul came into being in the womb of our mother). Therefore the soul
which is inside our body was not in the body of someone else who lived before
us on earth or in the body of an animal. So, brothers, don’t worry, for you
are not someone else; your soul is yours, you have never lived inside the
body of someone else before you were born in this world and thus you do not
need to know who you were in your previous lives. |
|
|
|
4)
The Holy Scripture teaches that when a man dies his soul goes either to
paradise or to hell, depending on whether he is saved or lost. Here is the
scriptural evidence. |
|
The
soul of the thief who repented on the cross went to paradise for Jesus said
to him: “Assuredly, I say to you, today you will be with Me in paradise”
(Luke |
|
The
souls of those men who had been slain for the Word of God, which John saw in
a vision, were in heaven under the altar that is before God. Here is what
John says: “When he opened the fifth seal, I saw under the altar the souls of
those who had been slain for the word of God and for the testimony which they
held” (Revelation 6:9 – NKJV). They did not reincarnate in anybody, either
immediately or after a certain period of time. |
|
The
apostle Paul knew and taught that when a righteous dies his soul goes to be
with the Lord, for he said to the Corinthians: “For we know that if our
earthly house, this tent, is destroyed, we have a building from God, a house
not made with hands, eternal in the heavens” (2 Corinthians 5:1 – NKJV).
That’s why he said to the Corinthians: “We are confident, yes, well pleased
rather to be absent from the body and to be present with the Lord” (2
Corinthians 5:8 – NKJV), and to the Philippians: “For I am hard-pressed
between the two, having a desire to depart and be with Christ, which is far
better” (Philippians |
|
Jesus
said that he who believes in Him, though he may die, will live (obviously in
heaven), as it is written: “He who believes in Me, though he may die, he
shall live” (John |
|
The
soul of the rich man, after he died, did not reincarnate in a poor man (or in
a pig or in a bitch – I have nothing against these animals) to expiate the
injustice he did to that beggar named Lazarus who was laid at his gate
covered with sores and longing to eat what fell from the rich man’s table.
According to the law of karma, the soul of the rich man should have
reincarnated in the body of someone who would be poor and covered with sores,
or in someone who would have to suffer as much as Lazarus had suffered at his
gate, but no reincarnation took place, for the soul of that man descended
into Hades where it was tormented by the fire, as it is written: “The rich
man also died and was buried. And being in torments in Hades ….” (Luke
16:22-23 – NKJV). He had lived in luxury and when he died he began to be
tormented; Abraham said to him: “Son, remember that thou in thy lifetime
receivedst thy good things, and likewise Lazarus evil things: but now he is
comforted, and thou art tormented” (Luke |
|
So,
since after death the souls of the righteous go to heaven (paradise) while
the souls of the wicked descend into the heart of the earth (Hades or Hell),
they can’t enter the body of those who are to be born or have just been born.
Brothers, when you finish the race that is set before you you will go to be
with the Lord, if indeed you are in the faith, and there you will wait for
the day of the resurrection of the righteous on which you will begin to live
again in a body (that is, in the body you have left on the earth), which will
be immortal, incorruptible and glorious, and you will appear before the
judgement seat of Christ to receive your reward. Instead, when the wicked die
they will descend into the fire of hell, as the Scripture says (cf. Job 21:13
and Psalm 9:17) and there they will wait for the judgement day on which they
will rise again, and will be judged according to their works and condemned to
an eternal shame. |
|
It
is written: “Man is destined to die once, and after that to face judgement”
(Hebrews |
|
|
|
5)
The Holy Scripture teaches that God directs the steps of both the righteous
and the wicked, who cannot understand fully how God directs them, as it is
written: “A man’s steps are directed by the Lord. How then can anyone
understand his own way?” (Proverbs |
|
Therefore,
to us believers, the fact that we were born in a rich family or in a poor
family, healthy or sick, did depend on God and not on previous merits or
demerits which we accumulated before our birth. Even the fact that we live in
a certain place, we have married a certain person, we have a certain job, and
we pass through certain circumstances, depends on God, who in a way we do not
understand directs our steps to do us good in the end. As He directed our
steps while we were lost in order that we might be saved, and thus to do us good, so we know that He still directs our steps to do us
good in the end. “All things work together for good to those who love God, to
those who are the called according to His purpose” (Romans |
|
As
for the wicked, it must be said that they also were born in a rich family or
in a poor one, healthy or sick, have married certain people, live in a certain
place rather than another, and have certain jobs, not because of some merits
or demerits they accumulated in their previous life, but because that’s the
will of God for them. However, while some of them will be saved by the Lord
at the appointed time for they are numbered among those whom God foreknew and
predestined to be adopted as His sons (cf. Romans 8:29-30), and therefore God
directs their steps so that in His own time they might come to the knowledge
of the truth, which will set them free; the others, being numbered among the
vessels of wrath prepared for destruction, will be guided by God in such a
way as to keep them from coming to the knowledge of the truth and thus to let
them go to perdition (cf. Romans 9:21-24). God has mercy on whom He wills,
and He hardens whom He wills; man’s salvation depends on the purpose of God
according to election and not on the will of those who preach the Gospel or
of those who hear it (cf. Romans 9:10-18). |
|
|
|
6)
The Holy Scripture teaches that man is recompensed while still on the earth
according to his deeds, as it is written: “If the righteous will be
recompensed on the earth, how much more the ungodly and the sinner” (Proverbs
11:31 – NKJV), and again: “Say to the righteous that it shall be well with
them, for they shall eat the fruit of their doings. Woe to the wicked! It
shall be ill with him, for the reward of his hands shall be given him”
(Isaiah |
|
However,
the deeds for which both the righteous and the wicked are recompensed on the
earth are the deeds which they do on this earth now, in this life, and not
the deeds which they did in previous lives they have lived. Therefore,
everyone reaps what he has sown in this life only (then when the resurrection
of the righteous takes place the righteous will appear before the judgement
seat of Christ to be rewarded for their deeds, while after the millennium the
wicked will rise again to be judged according to their deeds and condemned to
eternal punishment). This spiritual law was created by God and no one can
escape it or change it. As he who sows a seed of wheat will reap wheat in due
time, and he who sows thorns and thistles will reap thorns and thistles in
due time, on account of a natural law ordained by God, so the righteous who
sows peace and righteousness will be rewarded by God, while the wicked who
sows iniquity will reap all kinds of troubles and woes for he has broken the
commandments of God. |
|
|
|
7)
The Scripture says: “The Lord is the God of recompense, He will surely repay”
(Jeremiah 51:56 – NKJV). In other words, God repays those who do evil things
punishing them as they deserve. In the Scriptures there are several examples
which confirm this. Pharaoh and his household were struck by God with serious
diseases for Pharaoh had taken the wife of Abraham into his palace (cf.
Genesis 12:14-17); the house of Abimelech was struck by God with bareness for
Abimelech had taken the wife of Abraham (cf. Genesis 20:1-18); Nebuchadnezzar
was punished by God for his arrogance (cf. Daniel 4:1-37); king Jehoram was
struck by God with an incurable disease of the bowels for his wickedness (cf.
2 Chronicles 21:18-19), etc. Of course, believers also will be punished by
God if they give themselves over to what is evil in the eyes of the Lord. For
Paul says to the Colossians: “He who does wrong will be repaid for what he
has done, and there is no partiality” (Colossians |
|
|
|
8)
The Holy Scripture teaches that the fact that one suffers many afflictions on
the earth does not mean that he was unjust or wicked in previous lives. The
example of Jesus shows this very clearly; even though He was righteous,
sinless and blameless He suffered many afflictions. Why? Perhaps because his
karma was a bad karma, that is to say, because in His previous lives He had
accumulated many evil deeds which He had to expiate? Certainly not. He, as
the Son of God coeternal with God the Father, was with God before the
foundation of the world (therefore before His incarnation, but keep in mind
that Jesus was not the reincarnation of someone who had lived before Him, as
some wicked people insinuate) in a state of uncontaminated purity, for Peter
calls Jesus a lamb without blemish and without spot that “was foreordained
before the foundation of the world ….” (1 Peter |
|
|
|
9)
The Holy Scripture teaches that there is a wicked being called devil and
Satan, who, through the rulers of the darkness of this age and other wicked
invisible beings who obey him, incites people to sin, as it is written: “He
who sins is of the devil, for the devil has sinned from the beginning” (1
John 3:8 – NKJV), and in fact Cain killed his brother for he was of the
wicked one. And sin repays with death he who serves it, and makes him an
enemy of God. Therefore the evil deeds which are done by men cannot be
justified through reincarnation, for men sin because
they are ruled by a wicked invisible being that is stronger than them. It is
quite wrong, therefore, to affirm or to think that one is homosexual because
in his previous life he laughed at homosexuals, or that one commits adultery
with a married woman for in one of her previous lives she was her wife, or
many other similar things. The wicked are of the devil, and they must repent
of their wicked deeds, or else they will go to hell when they die.
Furthermore, the devil does another thing, that is, he strikes people with
all kinds of diseases; Satan struck Job, who was a just man, with painful
boils (cf. Job 2:7); he bound for eighteen years that woman who was bent over
whom Jesus healed (cf. Luke 13:10-17); and Satan, through a deaf and dumb
spirit, had struck that boy whom Jesus set free (cf. Mark 9:20-22).
Therefore, in certain cases, the misfortunes which both the righteous and the
wicked suffer are works of the devil, which God permits in their lives for
certain specific reasons. One of these reasons is to gain honor for His holy
name. |
|
|
|
10)
The Holy Scripture teaches that one day all believers will appear “before the
judgement seat of Christ, that each one may receive the things done in the
body, according to what he has done, whether good or bad” (2 Corinthians 5:10
– NKJV); that will take place when they rise again. Therefore believers will
be rewarded for their works on that day and not during alleged next lives on
the earth. God will reward all believers through Jesus Christ. That’s why we
are called to be zealous for good works, and as we have opportunity to do
good, while we are still alive, for after death we will not be able to do any
good works any longer, but we will have to wait for the day on which we will
be rewarded for what we have done. What we will have done will be done
forever; and what we won’t have done we will not be able to do any longer.
And that’s why we are called to abhor evil and flee it, for if we do evil
things we not only will displease God and dishonor His doctrine but we will
also suffer loss on that day, when we are to give account to God, the
righteous Judge, for the evil things done while in the body. |
|
|
|
|
|
11)
The Holy Scripture teaches that the wicked will rise again on the last day in
order to be judged according to their works and to be condemned to
everlasting torment. For John, who saw the souls of the dead come to life and
appear before the throne of God, says: “… And books were opened … The dead
were judged according to what they had done as recorded in the books”
(Revelation |
|
|
|
12)
The Holy Scripture teaches that God is willing to forgive the sins of those who
repent and believe in His Son Jesus Christ, for the prophet Isaiah says: “Let
the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts; let him
return to the Lord, and He will have mercy on him; and to our God, for He
will abundantly pardon” (Isaiah 55:7 – NKJV), and the apostle Peter affirms:
“All the prophets testify about him that everyone who believes in him
receives forgiveness of sins through his name” (Acts 10:43 – NIV). Therefore
all the debts which a man has incurred against our God can be forgiven freely
while he is still alive. The ‘law’ of karma excludes that a man may be
forgiven, but the Word of God affirms clearly that this can happen. The ‘law’
of karma, therefore, must be rejected for it is a lie conceived by the devil,
who is the father of lies, who wants to deceive people into believing that
their sins can’t be forgiven for there is no forgiving God. It is true that
reincarnationists sometimes speak about absolution and expiation, but they
are self-absolution and self-expiation for man is called to pay the ransom,
that is, the so called karmic debt. Reincarnationists do not mention at all
the ransom which was paid by Jesus Christ once for all when He offered
Himself to atone for our sins. Men – according to reincarnationists – must
pay off their debts (right down to the last penny); when they pay off their
debts then they will be saved (not from sin but from the cycle of rebirths). |
|
|
|
13)
The Holy Scripture states that “by one offering he hath perfected for ever
them that are sanctified” (Hebrews 10:14), which means that he who has
believed in Jesus Christ, has been made perfect forever in regard to the
conscience, through his faith in the blood which Jesus shed for our sins. For
the blood of Jesus is able to cleanse man’s conscience from all sins. We who
have experienced this cleansing certify that what the Scripture says is true.
Therefore, since the disciples of Christ have attained perfection – in regard
to conscience – through the precious blood of Jesus Christ, they do not need
to live other lives on the earth in order to cleanse themselves from their
sins for they have been cleansed by the blood of Jesus. As for those sins
which are committed after one’s conversion, they also are blotted out by the
blood of Jesus, for it is written: “If we walk in the light as He is in the
light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus Christ His
Son cleanses us from all sin” (1 John 1:7 – NKJV). That’s why believers know
that reincarnation and the ‘law’ of karma cannot be true, for the faith in
the perfect atoning sacrifice of Christ and in His precious blood nullifies
any doctrine which affirms that a man can expiate his own sins through good
deeds in this life or in alleged next lives. Reincarnationists often say that
it is impossible for most people to attain perfection during one life, that’s
why they need to live other lives. Instead, the Good News of the |